Holiday Pies, Bûche & Gifts
Make the season bright with our handmade holiday pies, decorate your own Bûche de Noël kit, and a selection of thoughtful bakery gifts. Each item is created in small batches with real ingredients and plenty of care.
Our grazing platter is also available for holiday gatherings. It features a curated mix of cheeses, charcuterie, and seasonal accompaniments, arranged and ready for your table.
From pies to giftable treats, you will find everything you need for hosting, celebrating, and sharing.
Holiday Dessert Table
Create a beautiful and memorable dessert table with our handmade holiday favorites. We offer a variety of festive options, perfect for gatherings of any size.
Decorate Your Own Bûche de Noël
A beloved holiday tradition and one of our most popular seasonal items. We provide a fully frosted family-sized Yule Log cake, crafted from moist chocolate sponge rolled with vanilla Italian meringue buttercream and covered in chocolate French buttercream.
Your kit includes everything you need to make edible decorations such as mushrooms, pine cones, field mice, and ladybugs, along with a link to an instructional video to guide your creations.
A delicious handmade cake and a fun activity for the whole family.
Contains nuts
Holiday Pies
Peanut Butter Pie
A customer favorite with a graham cracker crust, creamy peanut butter mousse, and a smooth chocolate ganache topping.
Cranberry Chess Pie
A bright and comforting seasonal pie where tart, burst cranberries mingle with a rich custard filling. The flavor is vibrant and refreshing, making it perfect for festive gatherings.
Cookie Platters
Our cookie platters are generously sized and filled with more than one hundred two-bite treats. Each tray includes a mix of holiday favorites, such as:
• Gooey fudgy brownies
• Buttery chewy blondies
• Spiced gingerbread cookies
• Mexican wedding cookies
• Holiday sprinkle cookies
• Chocolate crinkle cookies
• Classic chocolate chip cookies
• Raspberry jam thumbprint cookies
Beautifully arranged and ready to serve, these platters bring color, warmth, and plenty of sweetness to any celebration.
Special Holiday Hors d’Oeuvres
Our holiday hors d’oeuvres bring together vibrant flavors, thoughtful preparation, and beautiful presentation. Whether you are hosting a cocktail party, planning a festive gathering, or setting the stage for a cozy evening with friends, these options make entertaining effortless and delicious.
Grazing Platters
Our Grazing Platter offers a generous, thoughtfully curated spread for sharing and snacking. It features three standout cheeses and two artisan salames from the Driftless region of Wisconsin, offering bold flavors that go far beyond a traditional cheese tray.
The board is rounded out with crisp vegetables, fresh grapes, dried fruit, Marcona almonds, pretzels, and a selection of crackers, along with fig spread, honey, and a briny note for balance.
Platters can be customized to suit your gathering, from a fully vegetarian board to an extra hearty version with added salami. Ideal for parties, meetings, and holiday celebrations.
Tartlets and Canapés
Our tartlets and canapés are crafted for elegant, bite-sized enjoyment. Tartlets are baked in savory shells, while canapés are served on crisp bread. Each twelve-inch platter features a single variety, beautifully arranged and ready to serve. Quantities vary depending on the style of each item.
Available options include:
• Sour Cherry and Brie Tartlet
• Spinach and Artichoke Tartlet
• Seasonal Mushroom Medley and Gruyère Canapé
• Bistro Beef Canapé
• Smoked Salmon Canapé
• Slow Roasted Tomato and Fontina Canapé
• Bacon, Fig and Ricotta Canapé
These selections offer a refined yet approachable assortment, perfect for creating a festive and memorable holiday hors d’oeuvres table.
Holiday Gifts
Share something thoughtful, tasty, and handmade this season. Our holiday gifts are created with care, packaged beautifully, and ready for giving. Whether you are thanking a host, surprising a friend, or treating someone special, you will find something memorable in our seasonal collection.
Coffee Lovers Bundle
A perfect choice for the coffee enthusiast. Each bundle includes your choice of Caffè Umbria coffee, two house-made syrups, handmade toffee, artisan truffles, and our house biscotti, all presented in a reusable gift bag.
Gift Card Bonus
Give a little and get a little in return. For every $50 in gift cards you purchase, you will receive a $10 bonus voucher as our thank-you. This offer is available through December 31.
English Toffee
Handcrafted English toffee coated in rich dark chocolate and finished with pecans for a southern twist. Available in Pecan Toffee or Coffee Toffee.
Pecan Caramel Clusters
Toasted pecans layered with our homemade caramel, finished with a smooth, semi-sweet chocolate top. A classic holiday treat.
Ted Lasso’s Biscuits with the Boss
A pink box filled with buttery shortbread made with care and plenty of heart. A simple, joyful gift for anyone who needs a little sweetness.
Holiday Cookies
Our festive cookie assortment returns only for the season. Enjoy decorated snowflakes, spiced gingersnaps, jam-filled thumbprints, candy cane Nanaimos, and our celebrated biscotti.
Chocolate Santas
Created by Gail Ambrosius Chocolatier in Madison, these charming chocolate Santas add an artisan touch to any stocking or gift basket.